Sanibel Real Estate Search

Sanibel Properties for Sale

Our website features the best Sanibel real estate search for homes, condo, land and foreclosure properties available. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in the Sanibel real estate market? Sign up for a  Sanibel Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold!

Newest Sanibel Properties for Sale

$1,299,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 224061210 MLS
Absolutely breathtaking, this 3-bedroom, 3-bathroom single-family pool home in the Dunes of Sanibel Island is a rare gem! Nearly completely remodeled and upgraded throughout, this pristine property is open, airy, and bright, featuring numerous windows with plantation shutters that invite in the natural sunset. The shiplap walls add a touch of coastal elegance, enhancing the home's charm. Located close to the Sanibel Causeway, this home offers convenient access on and off the island. It is also near Sanibel beaches and just a short walk or drive to the Causeway beach, making it an ideal location for beach lovers. Overlooking a pristine golf course, this home offers a country club feel with amenities such as tennis, pickleball and an on site restaurant, without the need for membership. The rear of the home provides unparalleled, stunning sunsets that are sure to captivate. Step outside to find lush landscaping in every direction. The home boasts numerous upgrades, including a new washer, dryer, hot water heater, voice-activated blinds on picture windows with retractable screens, a remodeled upstairs lanai, a new metal roof, and a hot tub purchased in December 2022. In 2023, the downstairs area was completely remodeled, and a new pool pump and pool heater with a chiller were installed. Brand new GE Café series kitchen appliances were also installed, and the primary and guest bedroom were remodeled. The most recent 2024 upgrades include replaced pool coping, new driveway pavers, sealed pavers front and back, a completely remodeled upstairs area including the stairway, new front and back landscaping, a new garage floor epoxy, and freshly painted exterior and interior. This home is truly a masterpiece, offering luxurious living in an unbeatable location!

1021 Sand Castle Road, Sanibel

$525,000
2 Beds 2 Baths 224060520 MLS
Escape to the Sanibel Island lifestyle with this wonderful 2 bedroom, 1 bathroom second-floor condo that has been freshly renovated just for you! Located mere steps away from Causeway Beach, this condo offers the perfect blend of comfort and convenience. Want to make a grand entrance? You can even arrive by boat and dock at our brand new dock for a special showing! Experience the charm of one of Sanibel's only fully completed and reopened condo complexes, where ALL OF THE SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS have already been PAID. Inside, you'll find a recently remodeled unit featuring new granite countertops and appliances in the kitchen, as well as updated bathrooms with fresh granite countertops and faucets. And the best part? All the beautiful brand new furniture is included, making this a turnkey opportunity you won't want to miss! Indulge in the amenities that make this place truly special, like the signature double tennis courts, sailboat access boat docks and heated swimming pool. With low HOA fees, new metal roofs, updated AC condensers, and upcoming exterior paint jobs and railing improvements, this condo complex is poised to impress. Take a dip in the resurfaced, oversized heated swimming pool, a perfect spot for relaxation and rejuvenation. Currently part of a highly successful vacation rental program, this condo offers you the opportunity to continue this tradition. Curious about rental details? Just ask! Don't let this slice of Sanibel paradise slip away – make it yours today and start living the island dream!

1250 Tennisplace Court Unit B22, Sanibel

$6,500,000
5 Beds 4 Baths 224054052 MLS
New To Market on Sanibel Island: Welcome to your dream renovation project! Nestled on the sandy shores of the Gulf of Mexico in Sanibel, Florida. This elevated 2 story home offers an unparalleled opportunity to create your own coastal retreat. Situated on a generous 1-acre lot, this property provides direct access to your private beach, promising endless memories. This charming house stands ready for transformation to showcase the Gulf of Mexico's expansive waters from two oversized balconies, offering breathtaking yet peaceful vistas. Whether you're a homeowner with a vision or an investor looking for a prime opportunity, this property allows you to select every detail of your renovation, ensuring a personalized and luxurious home tailored to your tastes. Ideally located near the island’s best shopping and dining options, ensuring that essentials and entertainment are just minutes away. Enjoy the tranquility and exclusivity of a private beach, a true sanctuary for relaxation and recreation. Embrace the coastal lifestyle with the invigorating ocean breezes that sweep across the Gulf of Mexico, carrying the scent of salt and freedom as you explore world-class shelling spots. Paddle boarding through the gentle waves offers a peaceful escape, while fishing off the sandy shores promises thrilling catches and unforgettable moments. 3627 W. Gulf Dr had a new roof and sub flooring installed, and 2 new HVAC units that will convey. Please note, the living area of the home was not affected from the storm surge and the damage was sustained from a roof failure.

3627 W Gulf Drive, Sanibel

$1,158,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 224048264 MLS
Fabulous executive home in the much sought after Gumbo Limbo subdivision in the heart of Sanibel Island! A sprawling home and premium lot that has been fully renovated with high end luxury finishes - nothing cookie cutter here! Three spacious bedrooms with a split master bedroom retreat and a spa like master bath. A gourmet chef's kitchen is the heart of the home and features an extra large kitchen island - perfect for social gatherings! The floor plan is very fun and flexible - a large living room, dining area and tv room and a 21 x 21 recreation room with fireplace is perfect for a movie theater or game room. Custom cabinetry, ceramic tile flooring, recessed lighting - everything has been upgraded with only the best finishes! Guest bedrooms are spacious and located in their own wing. The outdoor area is a true oasis - disappearing slider doors blend the interior and exterior for an even larger living space. Pass thru kitchen window to an outdoor wet bar is another thoughtful feature. Pool Lanai has access to bathroom and there is a very large covered patio with Kevlar hurricane shutters for additional privacy and protection and a large sunning area. Sparkling pool for added enjoyment throughout the year and a large side yard with plenty of space to add an additional outdoor living space or small sports court. The property is fully irrigated and the gardens are simply beautiful - a front courtyard patio , a paved circular drive and lush landscape are in the front of the home while the backyard is private but also offers beautiful views and sunsets from the lake - this is paradise at its best! Sanibel Island is world famous for miles of beautiful white sandy beaches, some of the best shelling in the country and incredible offshore fishing! Enjoy easy access to Sanibel's bike path, shopping and restaurants - also easy access to Fort Myers! Live your best life on the island!

9421 Moonlight Drive, Sanibel

$44,880,000
6 Beds 8 Baths 224050501 MLS
Welcome to Mandalay! Where luxury meets tranquility in this private oasis. With 700 combined feet of pristine, prime beach frontage, a TRUE rarity in the coveted landscape of Florida. This home and the connected vacant lot, which both convey in this sale, offer just under five acres of landscaped bliss and a private boat dock on the Bayou. As you step through the grand entrance, you will be greeted by an ambiance of refined elegance and coastal charm. Built to commercial code in 2009, this fortress stands steadfast in its ability to withstand anything. The custom Tischler windows and doors were manufactured, imported, and installed directly from Germany to withstand winds over 200 mph. All the details were incredibly well thought out and far exceed Florida Building Codes. Prepare to be amazed both by the features and substantial quality! The spacious layout seamlessly blends contemporary design with timeless accents, creating an atmosphere of grand, yet understated luxury at its finest. Entertain with ease in the gourmet chef’s kitchen complete with walk-in cooler, top-of-the-line appliances, spacious full bar, butler’s pantry, a dream worthy center prep island, and the Gulf serving as the backdrop for the most unforgettable gatherings. The lavish primary retreat is a serene sanctuary featuring a private balcony, a remarkable fireplace for cozy curl-ups, and a spa-like ensuite bathroom with separate vanities and latrines for the utmost privacy. As if that isn’t enough, the sparkling pool displays a stunning spillover waterfall while a private path will lead you to the perfect place for soaking up the sun (or sunset) from the white sandy beach that makes Sanibel Island known as one of the BEST beaches in the sunshine state. This is not a HOME but an opportunity to own the MOST ULTIMATE coastal living experience! You must see it for yourself…

6111 Sanibel Captiva Road, Sanibel

$798,900
3 Beds 3 Baths 224048263 MLS
HEAVEN ON EARTH!!!!! The **CUTEST** beach cottage for sale in Sanibel! Think Olde Key West - charm galore, island colors, and an attached but private guest casita ! Curb appeal from the moment you pull up - circular drive with magnificent, mature and lush landscaping. Fully and luxuriously remodeled - great care was taken and major attention to detail on everything - no short cuts! Main home is two bedrooms - each with double slider access to outside patios. Upgrades include roof, windows, floors, baths, lighting, paint, appliances - basically a full and complete rehab! The great room features vaulted ceilings, a custom accent wall with fireplace and floor to ceiling tile. There is an extended living space /den that could be used for a variety of uses - music room, additional sitting/dining etc. A full wall of sliders allows in the natural light and showcases the beautiful views outside! Large kitchen island with level 5 countertops - upgraded cabinets with soft close and drawers in the island for practical use. The whole layout of the home is PERFECT for entertaining! Outside is again filled with charm, character and an oasis for relaxation. Plenty of space for a pool, fully fenced and a large extended paved open patio. South facing to enjoy the Florida sunshine! Located on a secluded street with easy walking/biking access to the beautiful beaches, shopping and restaurants. Sanibel is in the process of recovery from Hurricane Ian and each day brings it a little closer - a great opportunity for a buyer who wants to live on the Island! Live your best life!

534 Piedmont Road, Sanibel

$1,999,999
224044571 MLS
Fully rebuilt after Hurricane Ian devastated Sanibel, this gem is a once in a lifetime opportunity for a buyer looking for an impressive income stream. This quaint three unit Inn is located in the Resort Zone and has always been rented as a daily rental. Just steps away from the Donax St beach, it has consistently been a priority destination for visiting tourists that love Sanibel for its shells, beaches and small town vibe. While the second floor was not touched by Hurricane Ian, we have still upgraded it as part of our rebuild, new Central Air Conditioner, new furniture and enhancements were important in include. The other 2 units have been rebuilt in totality, ground up. Also new roof, new siding, new landscaping, we have focused on each part of the process with forethought and care to make this again a destination for guests throughout the Country and Internationally. This Inn has been rented on the major online accounts since 2017 and has built up a reputation for consistent bookings. 2024 calendar is already booking out, so a buyer will close with income already in place. In addition, many previous guests book direct and come back year after year. This special property is a 100 year land lease with over 50 years remaining and a smart and stable investment without the volatility of other investment options. With all the working policies and procedures already in place, a new owner can virtually take over an established business, streamlined with proven efficiencies and income.

610 Donax Street Unit 311, Sanibel

Start Your Search