Pine Island Real Estate Search

Pine Island Properties for Sale

Our website features the best Pine Island real estate search for homes, condo, land and foreclosure properties available. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in the Pine Island real estate market? Sign up for a  Pine Island Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold!

Newest Pine Island Properties for Sale

$1,189,000
4 Beds 4 Baths 224058147 MLS
LIVE THE DREAM WITH MINUTES OUT TO OPEN WATERS! Welcome to your dream waterfront home in beautiful St. James City! This fully remodeled 4-bedroom, 4-bath residence offers unparalleled luxury and comfort. Nestled on a direct access canal, a true boater's paradise with a 10,000-pound boat lift, just a few minutes to some of the best fishing, boating and islands in SWFL! As you step inside, you'll be greeted by a massive vaulted ceiling that is light and bright - a modern, open-concept living space with a dream kitchen high-end stainless steel appliances, sleek ceramic flooring, and stunning quartz countertops. Open to the living area and beautiful views from the window. The layout is thoughtfully designed with two master suites on the ground floor, each boasting en-suite bathrooms, perfect for multi-generational living or hosting guests. Upstairs, you'll find two generously sized bedrooms, one of which opens to a private balcony, offering serene views of the canal and the surrounding area. Step outside to your personal oasis where a sparkling pool and spa await, ideal for relaxing and entertaining. Whether you're lounging by the pool or enjoying a sunset cruise from your private dock, this home offers the ultimate Florida lifestyle. Don't miss the opportunity to own this exceptional property in St. James City. Schedule your private tour today and experience waterfront living at its finest! All the work has been done, just move right in!

2420 Cherimoya Lane, St. James City

$2,385,000
5 Beds 6 Baths 224042105 MLS
Step into a world where every sunrise paints the sky with pastel hues and every sunset sets the horizon ablaze with fiery brilliance. Welcome to your own sanctuary, where whimsy meets luxury in perfect harmony. Nestled along the picturesque Bay Front, this enchanting residence boasts five private en suites, ensuring unparalleled comfort and privacy for you and your guests. As you wander through the sun drenched halls, each window becomes a canvas showcasing panoramic views of the glistening bay front waters, inviting you to lose yourself in the tranquility of your surroundings. But the magic doesn't end there. Step outside into your own personal oasis, where a new heated salt water pool awaits, beckoning you to indulge in moments of pure relaxation. A New Standing Seam Metal Roof adds a touch of modern elegance to the timeless charm of your abode. For the avid boater, two boat lifts (new motors 2023) offer quick deep water access, where the allure of Sanibel Island, Ft Myers Beach and Cayo Costa beckon with their pristine shores and sun kissed sands. And for those seeking the thrill of the catch, the best fishing in Pine Island Sound is just minutes away, promising endless days of excitement on the open sea. With over 3700+ square of meticulously designed living space, every corner of this exquisite residence is a testament to the art of luxury living. So come, embark on a journey where every moment is infused with wonder and every day is a celebration of life's greatest treasures. Welcome to Paradise!

2272 Macadamia Lane, St. James City

$769,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 224046954 MLS
High and dry, Flood Zone X, No Flood Ins required!!! Beautiful 2014 Tundra built pool home in desirable Bokeelia, Florida. Come enjoy the best that island has to offer with 2.5 acres of fenced privacy and lush landscape. Room for all your toys with a 3 car oversize garage with a fourth garage door for drive through option. Garage comes equipped with RV hookup, welding hookup and transfer switch for generator. Plenty of space to have a horse or your own, chickens or goats, etc as zoning allows it. Bring your RV and Boat as they are both allowed to be parked on your own property. Neighborhood dirt roads allow for horseback riding, bike riding or driving your golf carts. You can walk or bike to fruit stand, goat yoga and pop up fruit stands in the neighborhood through out the year. Remote island feel but yet you are just minutes away from grocery stores, gas, bank and many great island local restaurants. Just minutes from boat launch and marinas to launch your boats and water crafts into the open Gulf waters with a quick boat ride you will be at Cayo Costa, Usepta, Sanibel and Captiva islands along with Lovers Key and Fort Myers Beach, Bonita Beach and Naples and Marco Island beaches. Or go north to Charlotte Harbor and Peace River or Boca Grande, Gasparilla Island, Manasota Key, Englewood, Venice and Siesta Key. The possibilities of fun from this Central location are endless fun in the sun in beautiful Southwest Florida.

12992 Aubrey Lane, Bokeelia

$1,680,000
5 Beds 3 Baths 224044872 MLS
This unique and beautiful 3-story home offers a rare opportunity to own a piece of paradise on Pine Island. Nestled on a serene 2.5-acre lot, this property features a stunning pool, a picturesque spring-fed lake, and an abundance of natural beauty. The home boasts 5 spacious bedrooms, with a versatile layout that includes 2 bedrooms and 1 bathroom in a separate living space. This area is perfect for extended family, guests, or generating additional income as a rental. Recently updated with impact windows and a brand-new roof installed post-Hurricane Ian, this home is well-prepared for Florida's weather challenges, providing peace of mind for years to come. The thoughtful upgrades enhance both the safety and the aesthetic appeal of the property. Stunning travertine flooring boarded by polished granite and mosaic inserts. Bedrooms are furnished with eco friendly bamboo floors. Step inside to discover a welcoming and airy interior, where natural light floods through large windows, offering stunning views of the surrounding landscape. The open-concept living area seamlessly connects to a modern kitchen, making it ideal for entertaining and everyday living. Outside, the expansive grounds offer endless possibilities. Relax by the pool, enjoy the tranquil lake, or explore the lush surroundings. This property truly embodies the best of Florida living, combining luxury, comfort, and natural beauty. Ideal for RV & Boat Parking. Garage features 4 car air conditioned spacious layout! Buried 500 gallon propane tank to provide what's needed when it counts! Don’t miss this rare chance to own a slice of paradise in Bokeelia. Schedule your private showing today and experience the unique charm.

5697 Bay Point Road, Bokeelia

$634,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 224043373 MLS
Cut the drive time down by skipping over Stringfellow Rd, straight to this upscale neighborhood! Spacious home with expansive outdoor living areas and room for all your toys. Own .62 acres off the beaten path while staying central! Open concept + split bedroom floorplan. Over 1900 sqft upstairs, 1900 underneath of storage/garage. Outside a separate 2400 sqft screened in decks & patio- a very impressive amount of space to stretch out. Transferrable flood policy only $900/yr, Homeowner policy is much less than other homes, due to all living quarters being on the 2nd floor. NEW gorgeous 48x9 'wood look' ceramic tile. 3 LARGE bedrooms with walk in closets. Big pantry and oversized hall closets will keep things organized. Stilt homes always have better breezes, and this one has 3 sets of French doors to usher them inside. New double decker pool cage with panoramic views. Relax to the sounds of a waterfall pool feature. Watch the colorful sunset & sunrise from the front and rear screened in areas. Garage under the home fits 2 full sized trucks, in addition to a workshop with electrical outlets along the ceiling and walls for your convenience. Also, a storage room with a window, tiled floors, closets and a/c (home office potential). Extraordinary pool area. Flowering plants provide picturesque privacy. 2 new pool pumps compliment the pool heating system. Guest bathroom has a convenient pool door. Exterior Hobby Room with tile, fan, lighting, outlets- right by the waterfront oasis. Enjoy fruit trees, pineapple plants and raised garden beds for years to come. This property has been lovingly looked after from the curb to the new fence along the backyard. Walk the freshly planted backyard tree trail to a hidden seating area by banana trees. Front & backyard have new irrigation on a timer. Hard wired security system. ************************************************************************ This upscale subdivision has underground utilities, all wires are buried, everyone has oversized lots and raised homes. Not an HOA. Walk to the library, school, community pool, community playhouse/theatre, ball field, tennis courts, 20 acre hiking trail... under 5 mins from 3 boat ramps, & the best burger in Lee County winner of 2024. You can't get any closer to town, while feeling like you are on an island retreat. Nothing beats the peace and sense of security this treehouse of a home provides. Here is everything you've hoped for, and as close as it gets, priced to sell at $103/total sqft. You had better come visit this one today!

10800 Habitat Circle, Bokeelia

$1,460,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 224044432 MLS
LOCATION! LOCATION! LOCATION! This impeccably maintained home in St. James City exemplifies quality construction, featuring elevated flood protection, ADA accessibility, hurricane shutters, a metal roof, and more. THE HOUSE HAD NO DAMAGE FROM HURRICANE IAN. AC is from 2020. Everything you see in the pictures is INCLUDED! Boat, Jet skis, furniture, games, EVERYTHING! Positioned on two lots, this property includes a heated pool, spa, sauna, and has remained flood-free due to its high elevation. It offers two boat lifts, including a 10,000-pound capacity lift with a composite dock. The home showcases a built-in breakfast nook with mitered windows that overlook the pool and canal, a walk-in pantry, and a large master suite with a walk-in shower. The guest bathroom also serves as a pool bath. Each of the three bedrooms has a spacious walk-in closet, providing ample storage. The oversized two-car garage offers additional storage, workshop space, or motorcycle storage. Located in a vibrant community, this home is just minutes from the Intracoastal Waterway and the Gulf of Mexico, including Sanibel and some of the best fishing in Southwest Florida. Enjoy the convenience of riding a golf cart to local restaurants and events in St. James City. The home is also close to marinas and shopping, with two grocery stores now available on Pine Island. This move-in ready home is a rare find. Don't miss the opportunity to experience the best of island living! SELLER IS MOTIVATED! Don't miss this amazing opportunity to own a vacation home, investment property, or your dream home.

2372 Sycamore Street, St. James City

$589,900
2 Beds 2 Baths 224040161 MLS
This charming waterfront bungalow is perched on a desirable canal on the southern tip of Pine Island…just a three minute sail out to Pine Island Sound and a short boat ride to Sanibel, Captiva and Ft Myers Beach. This charming cottage is situated in St. James City which exudes the essence of old Florida Living. The exterior boasts durability and sophistication with a new metal roof installed in 2021, complemented by fresh Hardi Board Siding and Impact Resistant Windows. For those drawn to the water, the 10,000lb boat lift and new seawall & dock installed in March 2021 provide effortless access to the glistening waters beyond. With ample space for a pool, the outdoor area invites relaxation and entertainment against the backdrop of breathtaking water views. Inside, modern updates from floor to ceiling make this home ready for you to move right in! The heart of the home lies in the kitchen, featuring new white cabinetry, open shelving, and butcher block countertops. A spacious center island with sink, eating bar, and granite countertop offers a focal point for gatherings and meal preparation. LG appliances, including a Counter Depth MAX French Door refrigerator, Easy Clean Glass Top oven, and Front Control dishwasher, elevate the kitchen's appeal and functionality. Throughout the main living spaces, nautical-inspired touches create a sense of coastal charm. Ceramic tiled wave walls, sliding doors leading to the back deck, and two nautical fans evoke a relaxed seaside ambiance. Porcelain floor tiles flow seamlessly throughout, complementing the ceramic tiled showers and subway-tiled walls in the primary bathroom. New cabinetry with stone countertops adds a touch of luxury and sophistication to the bathrooms, while the ceramic tiled wave wall in the primary bedroom provides a serene retreat. A new A/C was installed in 2023, new hot water tank in 2024, and new Samsung High Efficiency washer and dryer were also installed in 2024. The home rests on a solid concrete stem wall foundation, ensuring stability and longevity. A detached 1-car garage provides convenient storage space for vehicles and outdoor gear. One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged.

2436 Sapodilla Lane, St. James City

$469,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 224028980 MLS
Enjoy the peace and tranquility of island living in this super clean cozy cottage that sits on a 2/3-acre lot in a quiet neighborhood on Pine Island Southwest of Florida. It is within a few minutes walking distance to Tropical Point Park with available water access point for kayaks and small boats, 4 miles to local shops, restaurants, supermarkets, and under 5 miles to Matlacha - a small island known for colorful arts and fishing community. In late September of 2022, hurricane Ian hit hard on Sanibel and Pine Island and created significant damages to the entire area of Southwest Florida. Our property was in 4 feet of sea water, it was devastated. But we were determined to rebuild it and we did it in a record time. We proudly announce this property of ours was completely repaired and renovated by the first week of March 2023.Roof 2021 Today this property is more beautiful than before; its interior has been redesigned with a modern looking and with an open floor concept. It has new drywalls, new paint of course, all new doors, new floors, new kitchen cabinets as well as many new appliances. Most furniture is relatively new too. The master bedroom has a queen size bed and a full private bathroom, the second bedroom has a full-size bed, and the third bedroom has two twin size beds. There is a shared full bathroom at the hallway. The kitchen is fully equipped with cookware, dinnerware, drinkware, etc. Just grab some groceries at the market and cook a meal or visit the wonderful moms and pops restaurants nearby. There're 2 smart TVs, 2 bikes available in the premises and a beautifully heated swimming pool for your enjoyment; and full washer and dryer for your convenience. The property is ideal for those who prefer quieter neighborhood and for those who love water activities, fishing, walking, biking, visiting fruit farms, or remote-working or even doing nothing. It is also a great getaway for couples or families to vacation together. You will have full access to the cottage, tucked away from the hustle and bustle of the noisy city, where you can enjoy the peace and tranquility of island living that Pine Island has to offer. This home is on an extra large lot perfect for anyone who enjoys gardening , fruits and more. This home is currently a successful vacation rental home and is perfect for someone looking to get in that business !!

3582 Papaya Street, St. James City

Start Your Search