Pine Island Real Estate Search

Pine Island Properties between $200,000 and $300,000 for Sale

Our website features the best real estate search for between $200,000 and $300,000 properties available in Pine Island and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in the Pine Island real estate market? Sign up for a  Pine Island Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Newest Pine Island Properties between $200,000 and $300,000 for Sale

$220,000
2026031476 MLS
RARE opportunity to own just under 2 acres of AG-2 zoned residential property in the heart of North Ft. Myers! This unique parcel offers exceptional flexibility and is already improved with a 2-car garage, a separate 3-car garage, storage cargo container, and an additional storage building, making it ideal for car enthusiasts, hobbyists, contractors, or anyone in need of abundant storage and workspace. It has plenty of room to build your custom dream home, this property offers the privacy and freedom of acreage (1.98 acres) while remaining conveniently located just minutes from downtown Fort Myers, Ft Myers River District, shopping, dining, schools, healthcare, parks, and convenient to US 41. The property is surrounded by already established homes also on acreage. The entrance to this huge property is totally private with the usage on the back about 1/2 acre of the property with plenty of room to build or leave AS IT IS.

1325 Laurel Drive, North Fort Myers
$234,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2026020448 MLS
Welcome to 3677 Tangerine Drive in the laid-back waterfront community of Saint James City, Florida. This property presents a unique opportunity for investors, flippers, or buyers looking to create their own slice of paradise in a highly desirable coastal location. Situated on a generous lot, the home offers great potential with its existing structure and location. While the property does require rehabilitation, it provides a blank canvas for those with vision. Whether you're looking to renovate and resell, build equity as a primary residence, or create a seasonal getaway, the possibilities here are substantial. Saint James City is known for its relaxed island lifestyle, access to world-class fishing, boating, and stunning Gulf sunsets. With close proximity to marinas, local restaurants, and nature preserves, this location continues to attract those seeking the charm of Old Florida. This is a fixer-upper and will require repairs and updates throughout. Property is being sold as-is.

3677 Tangerine Drive, St James City
$225,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2026016275 MLS
Your Worry-Free Island Escape: Pristine Condo with Low Maintenance: The low monthly fee covers the heavy lifting of home ownership, providing pest control, insurance, and lawn care—allowing for a "lock and leave" lifestyle or just relaxing on Pine Island Time. Step into the heart of THE 'Island Center' with this exceptional condo near the Phillips Park, Tennis Courts, Library and Community Pool; as well as some of the Best Local Eats! Since Pine Island is long and spread out, being at "the Center" is a major perk and perfectly positioned for those who crave the "Old Florida" lifestyle while still being just minutes from local art galleries, fresh seafood markets, and the charming shops of Matlacha, and surrounding resort islands. Whether you're looking for a seasonal retreat, a high-potential rental, or a permanent slice of paradise, this unit offers the ultimate island home base. This condo's Flexible Layout features 2BR/2BA, attached garage, with plenty of natural light and coastal breezes under cathedral ceilings. The front dining room serves as a perfect "flex space" for a home office or den and with its Spacious & Bright flow through the kitchen and Florida Great Room; ceramic tile throughout. Enjoy peaceful front and backyard views, a screened-in lanai with views to a fenced-in, private backyard surrounded by shade trees and beautifully landscaped grounds that feel like a private sanctuary. This condo sounds like the quintessential "Old Florida" retreat, especially for someone who wants the perks of island living without the typical maintenance headaches; and with a quiet neighborhood setting, you'll have the perfect balance of convenience and tranquility while enjoying the best at an affordable price. Don't miss out on this incredible opportunity to live on an island in Paradise.

5520 Phillips Street, Bokeelia
$275,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 2026013549 MLS
Looking for a charming cottage with personality? Welcome to this recently renovated 3-bedroom, 1-bath single-family home in Bokeelia’s beloved “Fish Streets”—a local favorite known for its laid-back island vibe. This move-in ready home has all the updates you want without losing its charm. Inside, you’ll find a clean, refreshed space that’s ready for your furniture (and whatever style you’re currently into—we’re not here to judge). Step outside and you’ll really see the value—this oversized lot offers plenty of room for outdoor living, hobbies, or finally having space for your boat, trailer, or weekend projects. There’s even a large shed out back for storage, a workshop, or your next big idea. If you’ve been searching for a home with space, character, and a location locals love, this one checks all the boxes. Opportunities like this don’t last—schedule your showing today!

5935 Sea Bass Road, Bokeelia
$288,800
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2026012255 MLS
Back on the market at 'no fault of Seller' -- Buyer's financing fell through. Experience the quintessential Pine Island lifestyle in this beautifully appointed retreat, where tropical serenity & phenomenal flora & fauna meets modern accessibility. This charming island home is ideally positioned moments from local marinas, dining, shopping, and the island's iconic scenic bike path. The upper level radiates warmth, featuring a sun-drenched living area and two comfortable bedrooms. The kitchen serves as a focal point, elevated by exquisite Portuguese porcelain tile countertops and a matching backsplash. For relaxation, the screened lanai offers a seamless transition to the outdoors to unwind, overlooking peaceful views of lush surroundings; perfect for enjoying your morning coffee or evening cocktails. The lower level provides exceptional flexibility with a private-entrance guest suite, including a third bedroom, half bath, and expansive storage—an ideal setup for an art studio or workshop. With a new roof and water heater (2023), a fully fenced yard, and verdant mature landscaping & fruit trees on two lots, this home is a turnkey slice of paradise. Don’t wait---paradise is calling!!

5888 Sea Bass Road, Bokeelia
$263,000
225001937 MLS
MOTIVATED SELLER PRICED TO SELL RARE GULF ACCESS MIXED USE WATERFRONT LOT NO BRIDGES Don’t miss this exceptional opportunity to own one of the most versatile waterfront parcels in the highly desirable south end of Pine Island. This rare, build-ready lot offers direct Gulf access with no bridges, making it a boater’s dream, perfect for fishing, yachting, or island hopping. Zoned for both residential and commercial use, this property is ideal for investors, builders, or end users looking to create a private waterfront home, boutique business, or a unique combination of both. The possibilities are endless. A brand new seawall has already been installed, saving time and offering immediate value for your future plans. Set in a quiet, charming coastal community known for its relaxed island lifestyle, natural beauty, and premier water access, this property offers incredible upside in a market with limited availability. Vacant waterfront land with this level of flexibility and access is hard to find, especially at this price. The seller is motivated and ready to make a deal. Now is the time to secure your piece of paradise before it’s gone.

2891 Oleander Street, St James City
$270,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 224077294 MLS
Welcome to your own piece of paradise in Bokeelia, Florida! This charming single family home boasts 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, and a prime location near the Gulf of Mexico. Imagine waking up each morning and taking a short stroll to the nearby fishing pier to catch your dinner or enjoying a delicious meal at one of the local restaurants. The landscaped yard with a beautiful mango tree adds to the Florida feel of this quaint home, creating a serene and tropical oasis. With extra outbuildings and a covered parking area connected to a workshop, there is plenty of space for all of your hobbies and projects. The wooded area next to the property provides added privacy, making this home the perfect retreat from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. Whether you are looking for a peaceful getaway or a permanent residence, this home offers the best of both worlds. Don't miss out on the opportunity to own a piece of paradise in Bokeelia - schedule a showing today and make this dream home yours! This house and surrounding area has never flooded!

15925 Quail Trail, Bokeelia
$215,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 224090898 MLS
HUGE PRICE REDUCTION MOTIVATED SELLERS SAY MAKE ME AN OFFER!! 55+ GULF ACCESS BOAT RAMP for fishing and boating enthusiasts! St. James City is known for its secluded and relaxed atmosphere and that is exactly what this home possesses, plus more!! This home sits on a CORNER LOT which provides privacy and space! Step inside this immaculate 2 bedroom 2 bath home with many updates and finishes. Each bedroom offers an ensuite bath complete with spacious closets. The kitchen comes well equipped with nice appliances. The living room is inviting and bright. Just off the living room you will be delighted to have a beautiful Florida room fit for even more guests. This room would also make a nice office or gym. An outdoor oasis awaits, with access from either bedroom. Enjoy watching the game with friends in your screened in porch or enjoy cocktails and the most gorgeous sunsets amongst the breeze. Just steps off the deck is a Tiki Hut that has a Grill for BBQ's and entertaining guests! This home also includes a Wen 50 AMP HOME GENERATOR W/100 LB. PROPANE TANK!! Amenities galore including Clubhouse, heated pool & spa, pickleball, bocce and dog park! Need a place to store your boat or RV? No problem! Gated storage available!!

5029 Gulfgate Lane, St James City
Start Your Search